Department of Mathematics, Statistics
and Computer Science
Wim Ruitenburg's Spring 2011 MATH 1300-101
Last updated: March 2011
Comments and suggestions: Email wimr@mscs.mu.edu
Origins of Mathematics
Included please find a collection of
maps of the old Greek world.
There is limiting copyright on these pictures.
Pythagoras
The Naissance of Greek scholarly communities lies shortly after 600 BC.
Among the earliest Greek `scholars' is Thales of Miletus, who lived until 547
BC.
Scholars attempt rational explanations of the world around them.
Our interest is in the development of precise mathematical reasoning.
Pythagoras of Samos lived between 575 BC and 475 BC.
The Pythagorean school, started by him in Croton, was a half religious, half
scientific, community whose members are the only early source of information
about its founder's work related to numbers and geometry.
The membership of this school associated geometry and numbers with signs from
the gods.
Even today we hear talk of lucky numbers, of six six six, or of a special
meaning of the pentagram.
Consider the early Pythagorean belief that all numbers from geometry
must be rational numbers, that is, must be numbers that are fractions of whole
numbers, like 2/3 and 175/101.
We may go through the following speculation to prove it wrong:
- When we think of all rational numbers as points on a straight line, it
appears at first obvious that they `fill' the whole line.
There simply is no room for more points.
- On second thought, if the above argument were acceptable, then so would
the following:
- Draw a straight line.
On it, mark off the whole numbers 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and so on.
- There are gaps between the whole numbers on the line.
In the consecutive gaps, we can put the numbers 1/2, 3/2, 5/2, 7/2, 9/2, and so
on.
Now the gaps have width 1/2.
- Next cut the gaps again in half by inserting the numbers 1/4, 3/4,
5/4, 7/4, 9/4, 11/4, and so on.
Now the many small gaps have width 1/4.
- Next cut the gaps again in half by inserting the numbers 1/8, 3/8,
5/8, 7/8, 9/8, 11/8, 13/8, and so on.
Now the many small gaps have width 1/8.
- When we keep doing this, the whole line will be `filled' with numbers
that are fractions with as denominator a power of 2.
By the earlier argument, the line should be `full.'
Obviously it isn't, because numbers like 1/3 are missing.
So the earlier argument why all numbers on the line should be rational, is
fallacious.
- Next, we construct a number of geometry which is not a rational number.
Consider the right triangle whose shorter sides have length 1.
By the well-known Pythagorean Theorem, the hypothenuse has length the square
root of 2.
Let us use the letter h for this length.
So h times h equals 2.
Suppose, to the contary, that h equals a fraction m/n of positive whole
numbers.
Then
- n times h equals m.
- So also n times n times h times h equals m times m.
- So n times n times 2 equals m times m.
Now factor both sides into prime factors.
Then the left hand side has an odd number of prime factors 2, while the right
hand side has an even number of prime factors 2.
Contradiction.
So h is not a rational number.
The story goes that it was a member of the school itself, who first discovered
that some number of geometry is not a fraction of whole numbers.
Regardless, inside as well as outside the Pythagorean school, arguments
continue about what is true about numbers and geometry.
The most convincing arguments are in the form of proofs.
Alexander
Communities of interchange survived in the Greek world.
By about 325 BC, Alexander of Macedonia, known as Alexander the Great, had
conquered almost the whole civilized
world.
In his attempt to remove a despot, he became one himself.
Alexander and many of his successors, were great admirers of Greek
civilization.
Its culture spread, and for a thousand years Greek was the standard for
intellectual and international communication.
Euclid
The earliest popularly known significant work on mathematics is
Elements, written by Euclid of Alexandria around 300 BC.
The contents revolve around a rigorous introduction to the foundations of
geometry, as it had developed in the hellenistic world of his time.
What follows is an incomplete list of aspects that make Elements of
great historical significance.
- The text survived through history as the primary, and in many aspects
only, source on the most rigorous foundations of a significant part of
mathematics.
For the better part of two millennia it was arguably the most important
mathematics text known to exist.
- Contrary to `mathematics' elsewhere in the world, Euclid's
Elements is not just a list of truths about numbers and geometry.
Instead, a short list of assumed `true' principles is given, in the form of
axioms or postulates.
From these, less elementary mathematical truths are derived through rigorous
proofs.
This approach is nowadays universal, and is known as the axiomatic
method.
In current common practice, we no longer make distinctions between axioms and
postulates; we just talk about axioms.
The more important statements that we rigorously derive from the axioms, are
called theorems.
People often talk about theories when they refer to lists of axioms,
plus the theorems that follow from them.
- A collection of axioms from which one tries to prove all the
other `true' facts, is called an axiomatization.
The very look of an axiomatization may tell us a lot about the kinds of
statements one might expect to prove from them.
One of Euclid's axioms, associated with the parallel postulate, became
singled out as possibly derivable from the other axioms.
In other words, the parallel postulate was possibly redundant as axiom.
This conjecture was not resolved for more than two millennia, partly
because the concept of axiomatic method was barely understood.
We will not discuss what makes a rigorous proof, or how exactly rigorous
proofs are related to axioms.
Arguably the most important ancient thinker on that subject was Aristotle, who
was a few decades older than Euclid.
On the World Wide Web, go to any good search engine website, and search
for further websites by selecting the words Euclid plus Elements.
Survival
A serious part of Greek work survives to this day.
One reason is the recognized special value of Hellenistic achievements.
Another is a series of lucky coincidences which kept copies of old works in
existence until after 1450, when book printing secured their preservation.